Restoration

Hafod Colliery restored to Hafod Woodland 1995-7 By Huw Crompton

In 1994-5, project partners began a series of meetings to decide what should be done with Hafod. At this stage, Clwyd County Council’s mineral officer was the driving force. Other partners were the owners at the time British Coal, the local authority Wrexham Council amongst others.

Hafod tip had become a focus for trials bikes, and little else, to the point that families would travel up from Birmingham with their bikes on trailers. Kids from Johnstown rode straight in on improvised home made bikes.





Although less striking in profile than Bersham, the tip was a hill of the same height and mostly purple grey colour with very little vegetation, not much use to the people in Rhos and Johnstown, and really an eyesore especially from the recently built A483.

The funding for this new project was something of an issue, since unlike modern mines, there was no restoration fund as such. A company which had reworked the mine in the 80s and early 90s had liquidated, and a sum of money intended for restoration was lost. British Coal put forward a modest budget and appointed Groundwork Wrexham to lead the restoration phase.

Groundwork’s landscape architect put together a programme and funding package. A soil scientist was appointed together with two project landscape architects. Many community groups were consulted including local horse riders and walkers, at workshops in Johnston and Rhos.

Grants for the project were secured from the Forestry Commission and the Welsh Development Agency (WDA), and a design was drawn up in 1996 summarising the needs of the parties and the conditions of the funders. The main use of the Hafod tip was planned to be recreation around a network of tracks, with the greater area planted with trees separated by open meadows and grass borders around the paths

The job went out to tender in early 1996 and work began on site in the summer.

A major feature of the design is the stone armoured drains. These, in the event of a flash flood, stop the spoil heap from being scoured away where the streams run on steeper slopes at speed. Under the stones is a geotextile layer to hold things together. As the trees have grown larger they now help stabilise the slopes of the tip, but in the early years when the trees were very small, the rock armoured drains protected the tip from storm damage.

The stone drains made excellent habitat for small animals especially reptiles and amphibians, which using the new drainage network were pleased to make Hafod their new home.

In order to provide the right conditions for planting the trees, very large areas of the tip were dug over to the depth of 1m. A division of tracked yellow diggers advanced over Hafod like tanks across a muddy battlefield.







Many interesting objects appeared, all waste from the mine (for example pit pony bones and broken old wheeled tubs) went onto the tip not just low grades of coal and stone. To form the new soil, great quantities of odourless dried sewage cake in granule form delivered in sacks were dug into the new soil structure.

Another waste product, wood residue from a woodchip factory in Chirk, was dug into the top 1m to provide structure and just enough nutrients to help the trees without supporting a rich herb layer on the top.

This photo shows the agricultural method used to transport the material around, and the old bath house, curiously made from a yellow brick, still standing which was demolished in the spring of 1997. It is buried in the bank by the old railyard tracks a little upslope from where the car park is now.

The car park was built using funding from The WDA in 1997, actually right on top of the old colliery car park next to the baths in front of Caretaker Cottage. So when the visitor parks up to run the dog or whatever today they are parking in the same spot as the miner going to work. This photo shows the collection of vehicles typically found there during the restoration work.

The open areas to become meadow were improved, again using agricultural methods. A spring tine cultivator was used for the top 200mm, much shallower than the 1m needed for the trees and their much deeper roots, the sack in the background is full of dried sewage sludge.

80,000 trees were planted at the end of the winter in 1997. The nursery stock arrived in trays carried by vans, the trees were tiny, in little paper pots, like this pine that is being planted in the spring. An early idea to enclose the tree plots in rabbit proof fencing was dropped. It’s fair to say that the project team at that time really had little idea how successful the take on the trees would be and how many would survive and flourish.

The contract reached completion at the end of the spring in 1997 and Hafod Colliery was handed over to Wrexham County Borough Council then for the enjoyment of the public as Hafod Community Woodland. At the time it was the biggest new woodland in North Wales. What had been a few farmer’s fields before the mine was now a hill with a wide variety of wildlife habitats and places for local people to go and enjoy the views and fresh air.

Hafod Coal mine to Hafod Country Park: student resources by Huw Crompton and Gill Burt, December 2012

Or, how to turn a hundred acre domed coal mine tip into a park and nature reserve if you've not done it before: we had not, but we did the job. Good luck!

This information is suitable for those wishing to study in detail the process of the restoration phase, for students of and practitioners in: soil science, landscape architecture, mineral and mine engineering, restoration project management, human geography and related fields.

The project to restore Hafod to country park took place after the end of the working life of the mine and not subject to any planning conditions that would be in place for a more recent, current or proposed mine. There was a moral onus on the owners to do something with it, but no formally prescribed agenda. This situation had many benefits as well as drawbacks.

The benefits were that the after use design was not subject to minimum standards imposed by planners, and could be better than these, planning standards being all too often used as maximum standards The restoration design was tailored to community use in the 1990s rather than to a preconceived plan separated by some years from the restoration itself. The project team were also able to be in control of the financial structure of the project in a constructive way rather than the reverse.

The downside was that the funding situation was start from scratch with no capital or bond generated by mineral extraction sales, and limits to the scope of the project created by the lack of generous finance

The professional expertise required to put together the restoration package was: soil scientist, landscape architect, geologist, minerals scientist, mining engineer, safety officer, consultation officers, grants and fundraising officers, and project managers. Many of these tasks were carried out by the same person and the project team numbered around 6 to 10 core staff and any one time.

The long term ownership and maintenance were key factors in the design stage and Hafod was to be given to the public in perpetuity for the enjoyment of the local communities. No part of the mine footprint was to be sold and only a very small part was suitable for development. Other mines in the former coalfields have had long term problems in this respect (for example Rothwell Colliery in Leeds)

The consultation stage involved as many community groups and possible user groups as possible. In 1995, the actual use was for trials bikes and little else, this activity as trespass without the owner's permission, and this excluded other potential user groups.

From the outset, the use of Hafod as a nature reserve/woodland with good access and a footpath, route network and multiple leisure uses, was a self suggesting design, Hafod being a 41m high hill covering 36Ha on a large flat flood plain offering views of up to 40 miles in most directions. A woodland with walks is a typical afteruse of many coal tips especially where they are in close proximity to communities that can make good use of them in this way.

The scope of the restoration project 1995-7 did not include anything in the way of interpretation or art to permanently commemorate the life of the mine or the men working there. This section of work, often included in restoration, was shelved to be tackled in the future first with the stone summit sculpture in 2005 and then with more a comprehensive interpretation project in 2012.

Before the mine began working in the 1860s, a number of footpaths and bridleways had crossed Hafod when it was farmers' fields. Reinstating these links, and joining in with surrounding track networks, was possible in the footpath network design, using them as the starting point to make these more elaborate.

The footpaths and tracks were constructed with pedestrians, horse riders, cyclists, and maintenance access in mind. Theoretically, tracks to be used for timber extraction were designed, although the project was never realistically commercially viable tree planting for timber production. In practice, many of the tracks around and upon the tip already in situ and those from the former use of the mine were ideal for the new access network. This included the old railway sidings line and steeper tracks used by euclids (large quarry trucks) either for ascent (gentle gradients) or descent (steeper gradients). Other historic features such as the line of a former rope race, were desirable to keep with the tracks.

New tracks, especially those to directly serve the desires of walkers wishing to easily gain good views and have a short enjoyable walk were formed. At the time the gradient used for these was up to 1 in 12. Other tracks provided shallower gradients and combined with surface water drainage ditches.

Most of the tracks of different kinds were formed using bare coal tailings shaped to form a free draining berm in cross section. This was later perceived as a weakness of the restoration and subsequently, key sections of path have been surfaced in rolled stone and geotextile. At 2012, about 1.5km are surfaced, leaving 80% unsurfaced. In wet weather some of the unsurfaced paths are muddy and require the walker to wear wellies! In dry weather there is no such issue.

Soil creation, and storm drainage, were the other priority design issues. The soil scientist and landscape architect studied similar mines in South Wales to gain current good practice models. Coal mine tips are susceptible to storm scouring, being wholly made up land, and lack the stone core found at similar sized hills locally such as Beeston Castle (sandstone) and Dinas Bran (limestone). In the 1970s and 1980s Hafod had been spread out and reshaped to make it safe in aftermath of the Aberfan disaster.

The drainage design was based on a restored mine in South Wales and the design of this item at Hafod was based upon this project, thanks here to Mervyn Davies. This detail used rock armoured geotextile storm drains to all surface water drains steep than 1 in 100, where water might be moving at speed in thunderstorm conditions. Large sandstone blocks around 250mm were laid on top of the geotextiles, and made to look natural The need for the storm drainage was particularly acute in the first 10 years after the tree planting and since then tree roots have effectively bound and stabilised the majority of the surface area at Hafod.

Attenuation or retention ponds were created in several places around the lower areas of the park, to retain surface water runoff, manage the quality and flow of water running off into existing water courses at the base of the park, and allow silts and solid material carried off the tip to deposit in the ponds before entering the water courses in the surrounding countryside. These ponds were designed with wildlife as well as surface water drainage management in mind.

Four main types of soil creation were used: deep dig to 1m depth and improve with liquid sewage injection (tree areas); deep dig to 1m depth and improve with digging in dried sewage sludge (tree areas), deep dig to 1m and improve with digging in wood residue (tree areas), and shallow harrow to 200mm and improve with wood residue and dried sewage sludge (meadow and open areas) The deep dig took 30 diggers 6 weeks over the whole site about 75% by area. The deep dig was to provide enough structure in the new soil for the trees' roots to be able to penetrate with enough nutrients and water for them to grow well, but not support a competing herb layer. The application rate was 100L per m2 for the deep dig areas and 20L per m2 for the shallow harrow areas.

The method for application of the liquid sewage was to use a tracked vehicle (to minimise compaction of deep dug shale) pulling a purpose built specialised tine which injected liquid sewage deep into the root layer of the deep dug shale. This involved a very long hose carrying the sewage from tankers to the injection tine. Care had to be taken to ensure the sewage remained in the deeper layers of the shale rather than running over the surface. This method had been pioneered in South Wales with some success. Liquid injection was only used on small areas of the tip and the use of dried sewage in sacks was the main one by area.

The method for the application of the dried sewage sludge was to deposit sacks around the site, then to slit, lift and swing the sacks to spread the sludge, prior to the deep dig which was called 'the intimate mix'. The sewage was inert and odourless at each stage wet or dry, before and after incorporation, and any reports of 'sewage smells' from this stage of the restoration were not based on fact.

The tree species planted were those mainly native to NE Wales. The tree species used were as nurses: larch, pine, birch and alder. These were intended to be removed in batches at years 10, 20 and 30 or thereabouts. As broadleaved woodland oak, bird cherry, gean, field maple, willow, rowan. The trees were planted as 25mm paper pot transplants, very small potted stock. As shrubs: gorse, hawthorn, broom, scotch rose, viburnum were planted. In the car park, dwarf pines and a mix of the trees found on site were used. A small number of horse and sweet chestnut were added to the mix. Willows were used more extensively above two former lagoons most recently in use, because of a higher water table in this location and a perceived need to speed up the drying out process.

Tree spacings were generally 3m centres for the hardwoods, 2m for the softwoods and 1m centres for the shrubs. Some areas of Hafod have not been planted to these spacings, as a result of one contractor using operatives unfamiliar with the type of work. Most of the planting was carried out before easter 1997 by skilled experienced operatives.

The tree planted area to open areas ratio was about 75% to 25%. The open areas included around 5m either side of the tracks, around the ponds, clearings at the top and bottom, and an open elevated basin on the west side

Local provenance was specified in the contract documents. This means trees grown from locally sourced seed. In practice, the numbers needed, and cost cutting contractors on the job, meant that this was not the case and trees sourced in Poland and elsewhere arrived on site. Neighbouring trees of the same species can be seen to have different leafing out times and other differences such as leaf shape and habit.

The post-completion tree growth has been very rapid 1997 to 2012. The nurse crop is ready for removal in most areas and in some locations is likely to obstruct views, as well as swamp slower growing trees. If the nurse crop is not removed before year 20 then the trees will be too large to be removed without damaging the neighbouring trees.

Comparative growth rates are visibly smaller trees in the upper and more exposed sections of Hafod and larger trees in the lower and more sheltered sections. On the steeper slopes, trees have shaped themselves to the local topography with leaning trunks and branches running parallel with the ground.

In many areas, the stone armoured drains have proved to be very suitable places for self seeding and regeneration, particularly the birch, alder and willow. This has been left largely unmaintained.

The restoration project has been a success at Hafod thanks to a combination of factors not the least of which is the long term commitment of the current owners. Given that the tips at Bersham (going) and Llay (gone) no longer commemorate the importance of the North Wales Coal fields, the fact that Hafod tip is still there in a similar form to when the mine closed, makes Hafod more important, representing the landscape and cultural impact of the whole of the coal field, even though there are no remaining surface buildings.

Space exists for more elaborate visitor facilities on level ground just to the south of the existing car park, should future conditions prove to be favourable for this, particularly in the context of the short term prospects very close by at Bersham and its very good surface buildings.